The Secret Sauce

The Secret Sauce

We live in a world where we seek professional advice in almost every facet of our lives. We have our insurance agent, dentist, hairstylist, lawyer, tax preparer, financial advisor, IT specialist, mechanic, chiropractor, handyman, doctor - the list goes on. When it comes to hiring these professional services, we rarely think twice, and rightly so.

However, when it comes to strength training, we often hesitate to make the investment, assuming we can achieve the desired results on our own. Occasionally, we set aside this reluctance and hire an exercise professional, but with caveats like, “I just want to learn how to do this on my own,” or “I’m just trying this out for a little while.” Ironically, these same individuals are often the first to acknowledge the complexity of exercise and the difficulties they encounter when attempting to go it alone.

This approach to resistance exercise has several pitfalls:

  1. Lack of Knowledge: The human body is a complex machine, and understanding how to train it effectively requires expertise.
  2. Misguided Regimens: Without proper guidance, it’s easy to adopt unsustainable routines or ineffective techniques.
  3. Proliferation of Myths: Misconceptions abound due to the widespread misunderstanding of exercise science.

However, the biggest issue is the absence of proper supervision.

The Importance of Supervision

Research consistently shows that the benefits of resistance exercise significantly increase with greater supervision.

A 2017 study published in BioMed Research International compared supervised resistance exercise (working with an exercise professional) to unsupervised resistance exercise (working out alone). The study focused on older adults participating in a progressive, high-effort resistance program over six months. The findings were stark:

  • Supervised Training: Participants experienced improvements in strength, body composition, functionality, and well-being.
  • Unsupervised Training: Participants saw no measurable benefits—essentially equivalent to not exercising at all.

Furthermore, a 2024 study examining the same topic looked at three different study groups:

  1. Participants training on their own
  2. Participants training with a workout partner (spouse, friend, gym buddy, etc.)
  3. Participants training with a certified personal trainer

The results were very telling:

  • Group One: Gained the least muscle and did not lose any fat.
  • Group Two: Gained more muscle than Group One but did not lose any fat.
  • Group Three: Gained the most muscle and simultaneously lost fat.

In both studies, the researchers noted that the difference came down to effort and accountability. Without supervision, we simply don’t work as hard.

Supervision Ratios and Results

Recent research has further explored the relationship between supervision ratios (e.g., 1:1 vs. 3:1) and training outcomes. The evidence is clear: as the ratio of supervision improves, so do the benefits. A lower trainee-to-trainer ratio allows for more personalized coaching, leading to higher effort levels and better results.

Key Takeaways

  1. Train with an Exercise Professional: Supervised training consistently outperforms unsupervised training. This becomes even more crucial as we age.
  2. Consider One-on-One Sessions: The more personalized the coaching, the greater the benefits. A smaller trainee-to-trainer ratio enhances results.

When it comes to resistance exercise, investing in proper supervision is not just a luxury, it’s a necessity for achieving real, sustainable results.

‍

Make 2022 Your Best Year Ever

Every new client receives a Free Introductory Session.

Book Your Free Introductory Session Now